EGYPT TURMOIL: A clash of civilizations (with video) Comment on this post ↓
August 15th, 2013 by Warren Swil

Islamists vs. secularists:

Battle between world views

Former Egyptian leader Mohamed Morsi, overthrown in a coup last month. Click image to enlarge.

AS THE CRISIS IN EGYPT deepens it is becoming increasingly apparent that the enormous gulf that has opened up between the two sides represents a titanic clash of civilizations.
On the one side is the Muslim Brotherhood, whose leader, elected president Mohamed Morsi was deposed in a coup last month.
On the other is the Egyptian military, supported for decades by huge infusions of cash from the United States, which would prefer a secular government.
The clashing world views seem, alas, to be irreconcilable.
The only foreseeable outcome is worsening violence and a protracted civil war.


I FIRST BLOGGED about this concept on June 18 in “Are Ottoman empire remnants collapsing.
What seems to be happening throughout the region is the implosion of artificially created nation states that never were “countries” when their borders were drawn.
Perhaps the clearest example of this can be seen in the plight of the Kurds, a tribe whose membership spans the borders of several countries.

If Kurdistan were a “country” this is what it might look like. It would cross several national borders. Click image to enlarge.

If it were a country, “Kurdistan” would include portions of Turkey, Iraq, Syria, and Iran.
This tight-knit group was completely ignored when the map of the modern Middle East was redrawn by the British and French in the late nineteenth century.
If this were the only problem, there might be a solution in creating a Kurdish homeland.
But it is not.
Within many of the countries in the region, there are deep divisions along both tribal and religious lines.
In Iraq, a prime example in this analysis, it was the Shiite majority long suppressed by the Sunni Ba’ath party, which for decades was led by Saddam Hussein.
Since the U.S. invasion of 2003, the Shiites have been resurgent, but the Sunnis have fought back tenaciously and the country today is teetering on the edge of civil war.

IN SYRIA, IT IS THE ALAWITE minority represented by President Bashar al-Assad that is desperately trying to cling to power against a collation of opposition forces ranging from secular democrats to Islamic Jihadists.
Thousands have died and millions have fled the country since the civil war began more than two years ago.
Although Egypt has a long history – longer than most western countries, in fact – the society is riven with religious rivalry that has emerged in the modern era.
The Islamists – perhaps has many as half the population – want a religious regime, and elected Morsi in what was deemed a fair and democratic election.

Al Jazeera is providing comprehensive coverage of the crisis in Egypt. Click image to enlarge.

The military was never happy with this outcome, but for more than a year it acquiesced.
Then, in early July, the protests began and provided the generals with the opportunity to take action “in the name of the people.”
The situation in Turkey is remarkably parallel.
After decades of secular rule (with a strong military undertone) that made the country a candidate for membership in the European Union, Recep Erdogan of the ruling Justice and Development party became its prime minister in 2003.
The country has since been drifting towards a more religious authoritarianism.
Clashes with its Kurdish minority bring us full circle to the implosion of what was once the Ottoman empire.
It represents a clash of civilizations like no other on earth.
It is modernism vs. traditionalism; tribalism vs. nationhood; secularism or religious authoritarianism.
There is no easy solution. Perhaps the dissolution is inevitable; many of these countries should never have existed in the first place.
We are, today, seeing the consequences of historical errors made by the colonial powers of the nineteenth century come back to haunt us. It is a human tragedy of vast proportions.

Watch the video: Hundreds killed, thousands injured in Egypt violence


FEEDBACK: Contact site admin directly

Email Administrator

3 Responses  
  • Uninformed observer writes:
    August 15th, 2013

    What is happening in Egypt is such a tragedy.
    It seems that throughout the Middle East democracy is fragile at best.
    Perhaps dictatorships are the best form of government for these people at this time.
    Bring back Saddam Hussein!

  • Bjorn in San Diego writes:
    August 15th, 2013

    I am originally from Sweden, but have lived in the US for many years (Over 30!) The Swedish government have been horrible in integrating immigrants, particularly those of Muslim back ground, since they do have “traditions” that seems very different from a modern country like Sweden. There are many sad cases where Muslim families who are strict Sharia law believers have killed there own children maybe because they were gay or didn’t want to marry someone the parents have picked out! That kind of behavior does NOT belong in a western society! Sadly, the government of Sweden have not done to much about this for fear of not seeming “multicultural” enough, or worse racist!

  • Warren writes:
    August 15th, 2013

    Integrating minority communities in EVERY democracy is a challenge, Bjorn.
    Look at France … It’s been awhile since the riots there, but not that long.
    The hallmark of a TRUE democracy — where the majority DOES rule — is how well it protects the rights of the minority.
    Gays are a tiny fraction of the US population, but would you argue that we have made great strides in protecting the rights of THIS minority in out country?
    I doubt it.
    Of course, the civil rights struggle in America is not yet won.
    But, in Egypt, elections were held and the Muslim Brotherhood candidate won.
    The army had no right to throw him out.

Post a Comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

»  Substance: WordPress   »  Style: Ahren Ahimsa & Martin Black